A reply to a review has two readers. The guest who wrote it reads it once. Everyone deciding whether to book with you reads it afterwards. Write for that second reader.
Guests notice. In BrightLocal’s 2026 survey of 1,002 US consumers, 89% said they expect owners to respond to reviews, and 50% said generic or templated replies put them off (BrightLocal, 2026). It is a US panel run by a company that sells review tools, but the direction is clear enough.
What Google recommends
Google’s own tips for review replies are short (Google Business Profile Help):
- Be professional and polite.
- Keep it short and simple.
- Be conversational, not promotional. Don’t use a reply to push deals.
- Never share a reviewer’s private information, and never attack them personally.
Google also points out that negative reviews aren’t necessarily a sign of poor business practices. A calm reply to a fair complaint can do more for you than ten thank-yous.
How to reply
Open your Business Profile, choose Read reviews, then Reply next to the review (Google Business Profile Help). Once approved, the reply appears under the review in the name of your business, not your own.
A method for any review
- Read it twice, and check the facts with your team before you write.
- Thank them for one specific thing they mentioned: the dish, the room, the server’s name.
- For a complaint: say what went wrong in your own words, explain briefly without excuses, and say what you changed or how to reach you directly.
- Keep it to two or three sentences.
- Sign it with a first name, so a real person is answering.
- Reply within a few days, while the visit is still fresh.
Example replies
Use these as a starting point and change the details every time.
What not to do
- Don’t argue, even when the review is unfair. Readers side with the calmer voice.
- Don’t offer a discount or a free meal in exchange for a review, or for changing or removing a bad one. Google forbids it, along with asking only happy guests for reviews (Google Maps content policy).
- Don’t pressure guests to leave a review while they are still at the table, and don’t tell them what to write. Google lists that too.
- Don’t post reviews yourself or let your staff do it. In Canada, the Competition Bureau says anyone who writes or allows reviews that give a false or misleading impression could be liable under the Competition Act (Competition Bureau Canada, 2024). In the US, the FTC’s 2024 rule bans buying fake reviews and rewarding reviews that express a particular sentiment (FTC).
- Don’t paste the same reply under every review.
Getting more reviews, the fair way
Ask every guest, not only the ones who look happy, and make it easy to say no. A line in the follow-up email or a short link on the receipt lets guests write a review later, at home. Don’t ask them to write it at the table, and never tell them what to say. Reviews feed your local ranking, so this is part of restaurant SEO.
What to measure
Track four numbers each month: new reviews, average rating, the share you replied to, and how many days a reply took. Write down where they are today, so you can see the change.
Questions owners ask
Question 1
Should I reply to every review?
Yes, including short ones and reviews with stars and no text. A one-line thank-you is enough there. Save the longer replies for reviews that raise a point.
Our answer
On Found Online, replies to your reviews are part of the monthly work. See what Found Online includes.
Question 2
Can I get a bad review removed?
Not because it is negative. You can report a review that breaks Google’s policies, for example one that is fake, off-topic or abusive, and Google decides. For the rest, a calm reply is your answer.
Our answer
We report reviews that clearly break the policy, and reply to the others in your voice.
Question 3
Should the owner reply, or the manager?
Whoever can reply quickly and knows what happened. Signing with a first name matters more than the job title.
Our answer
The free audit looks at your Google profile, including your reviews and replies, and tells you where to start.
Sources
- BrightLocal, Local Consumer Review Survey 2026 (US panel, vendor survey)
- Google Business Profile Help, tips to get more reviews and write better replies
- Google Business Profile Help, manage customer reviews
- Google Maps user contributed content policy, prohibited and restricted content
- Competition Bureau Canada, online reviews posted by employees (2024)
- FTC rule on consumer reviews and testimonials, 16 CFR Part 465

